top of page

Holiday, Regular & Premium Cheesecakes

NOTE: Many of our holiday-themed cheesecakes are available year 'round. Just check the description for information. We can also customize ANY cheesecake for you! Just let us know what you want!

"The Resolution"

New Year's: (9" cheesecake) (Available only when eggnog is sold in stores!) 32oz of cream cheese is blended with Southern Comfort brand eggnog and baked over a graham crust, then topped with whole cranberries and a cranberry glaze. Contrary to its namesake, you may want to put your New Year's resolutions off until AFTER trying this one!

$35.00

"The Cupid Trio"

Valentine's Day: (Available year 'round) You'll receive a platter of (3) heart-shaped cheesecakes (each approx. 4.5" inches wide) that are the perfect size! The cakes in our picture are covered with a buttercream glaze and assorted toppings, but you can request any kind of topping/deco that you'd like. Just right for that special day, or any other time!

$20.00

"All My Peeps"

Easter: (9" cheesecake, available only when "Peeps" chicks are sold in stores!): 32oz of cream cheese filling, flavored with your choice of plain, blueberry or strawberry (we blend fresh fruits into the filling for our flavors.) Then it's topped with a cream cheese frosting and...Peeps!

$35.00

"The Carrot Patch"

Easter: (9" cheesecake, available year 'round): This is a three-tiered cheesecake. 2 layers of moist carrot cake surround a 16oz layer of cheesecake, with a topping of cream cheese frosting. Perfect for Easter, but great anytime at all!

$40.00

"The Patriot"

4th of July: (9" cheesecake, available year 'round): Triple-layer cheesecake. 16oz of New York cheesecake is surrounded by red and blue layers of moist vanilla cake and topped with cream cheese frosting, blueberry/frosting "stars" and frosting "stripes." A great way to celebrate Independence Day, fireworks and cookouts!

$35.00

"The State Fair"

State Fair: (9" cheesecake, available year 'round): A cinnamon graham crust is filled with apple pie filling and 24oz of cheesecake batter, then topped with a layer of Kraft caramel and a brown sugar crisp. Perfect for the Fall, celebrating the arrival of the Fair, or anytime at all!

$35.00

"The Graveyard Shift"

Halloween: (9" cheesecake, available only when "Gummi" monsters and the Wilton Gravestone Kits are available. This is a triple layer cheesecake, with two layers of moist vanilla cake (colored orange) surrounding 16oz of cheesecake batter (colored green). It's topped off with cream cheese frosting, chocolate chip cookie "dirt" on the sides, Oreo "dirt" on the top, with assorted ghouls, candy bones and gravestones. All edible! This is a MONSTER cheesecake, and a truly "chilling" experience!

$40.00

"Devil's Delight"

Halloween: (9" cheesecake, available year 'round): This is a triple layer cheesecake, with two layers of moist Devil's Food Cake surrounding another layer of 16oz of cheesecake, with fudge frosting throughout. It's then topped with more fudge frosting for the ultimate finish. Despite the name, it's a heavenly cheesecake experience!

$40.00

"The Pilgrim"

Thanksgiving: (9" cheesecake, available year 'round): This is a double-layered cheesecake, with one layer of regular cheesecake batter over a crushed Nabisco Ginger Snaps crust, and another layer of pumpkin pie cheesecake on top of that. Topped with whipped cream and pecans. Save some room at Thanksgiving dinner for this one! (If you're not a fan of ginger snaps, this can be changed to a cinnamon graham crust...just let us know!)

$30.00

"T'is The Season"

Christmas: (9" cheesecake, available year 'round): A gingerbread cheesecake! We make a fresh Nabisco gingersnap cookie crust and fill it with a cheesecake batter with hints of ginger, nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, molasses and brown sugar. Topped with white icing and gingerbread cookies. Great for the holidays!

$30.00

New York-Style Cheesecake

The mother of all cheesecakes! We take 2 pounds of cream cheese, add the ingredients and bake it into a pecan sandy cookie crust (this crust DOES have nuts; if you'd like a graham crust instead, please let us know!) This is a LOT of cheesecake, and it'll definitely be a hit with you and your guests. Add a fruit topping (cherry, blueberry, strawberry) for an additional $5.00

$30.00

Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

16oz of cream cheese is blended with sour cream, eggs, sugar and a hint of vanilla, then baked into a crushed chocolate chip cookie crust, with semi-sweet morsels on top

$30.00

Mocha Chocolate Cheesecake

For coffee lovers! 24oz of cream cheese (24oz) is blended with sour cream, eggs, sugar, brown sugar, vanilla and freshly-brewed coffee, then baked into a crushed chocolate chip cookie crust with a chocolate glaze on top

$35.00

Maple Pumpkin Cheesecake

24oz of cream cheese is blended with pumpkin, sweetened condensed milk, eggs, sugar, maple syrup, cinnamon and nutmeg, then baked into a graham crust, with maple pecan glaze on top

$30.00

Triple Layer Lemon Cheesecake

The filling is made with 24oz of lemon-flavored cream cheese filling, a layer of sugar/vanilla sweetened sour cream and a layer of lemon glaze. It's then baked over a crust of crushed lemon cream cookies.

$30.00

Key Lime Cheesecake

32oz of cream cheese is blended with genuine Nellie & Joe's Famous Key Lime juice, lime zest, baked over a graham crust and finished with a sweetened sour cream topping. It's the next closest thing to being on a Florida beach!

$30.00

Oreo Cookie Cheesecake

32oz of cream cheese is blended with semi-sweet chocolate chips, baked over a crushed chocolate cream-filled cookie crust and topped with Hershey's chocolate and crushed Oreo bits

$35.00

Butterscotch Cheesecake

24oz of cream cheese is blended with butterscotch pudding, baked over a graham crust and topped with a caramel glaze and crushed butterscotch candy

$30.00

Brownie Cheesecake

24oz of cream cheese filling is baked over a Ghirardelli brownie crust and a layer of caramel, then topped with a chocolate layer and drizzled with more caramel

$30.00

Sweet Potato Cheesecake

If you love sweet potato pie, then this one's for you! 24oz of cream cheese is mixed with sweet potatoes and spices, baked into a graham crust, then topped with a brown sugar/pecan creamy glaze

$30.00

Caramel Praline Cheesecake

32oz of cream cheese is mixed with sour cream, brown sugar and vanilla, baked into a graham crust, then topped with a Kraft Caramel layer & pecans

$30.00

Black Forest Cheesecake

32oz of cream cheese is mixed with sour cream, melted semi-sweet chocolate and vanilla, baked into an Oreo cookie crust, then topped with Cool Whip and whole cherries/glaze

$30.00

Chocolate Truffle Cheesecake

24oz of cream cheese is mixed with sweetened condensed milk, vanilla and melted semi-sweet chocolate and baked into an Oreo crust. Topped with a Hershey's chocolate ganache.

$30.00

White Chocolate Cheesecake

32oz of cream cheese is mixed with Baker's Premium White Chocolate, sour cream and vanilla, and baked into a vanilla crust. Topped with white chocolate curls.

$30.00

Triple Citrus Cheesecake

32oz of cream cheese is mixed with sour cream, vanilla, zest/juice from lemons, limes and oranges and baked into a graham crust. It's topped with a citrus glaze. The perfect summer cheesecake!

$30.00

Orange Butterscotch Cheesecake

24oz of orange-flavored cream cheese filling is baked over a graham/brown sugar crust, then topped with a butterscotch glaze.

$30.00

Coffee Toffee Cheesecake

24oz of cream cheese filling is infused with semi-sweet chocolate and fresh-brewed coffee, baked over a chocolcate chip cookie crust, then topped with a semi-sweet chocolate ganache and Heath Bar English toffee bits

$35.00

Strawberry Explosion Cheesecake

32oz of fresh strawberry-infused cheesecake filling is baked over a homemade graham crust and topped with with a fresh strawberry-infused cream cheese topping. There's a total of 40oz of cream cheese in this strawberry extravaganza!

$35.00

Blueberry Explosion Cheesecake

32oz of fresh blueberry-infused cheesecake filling is baked over a homemade graham crust and topped with with a fresh blueberry-infused cream cheese topping. There's a total of 40oz of cream cheese in this blueberry extravaganza!

$35.00

Reese's Peanut Butter Cheesecake

PREMIUM (10" cheesecake): 32oz of cream cheese is mixed with creamy Reese's Peanut Butter, brown sugar and vanilla, then baked in a crushed Oreo cookie and peanut crust. If that wasn't enough, it's topped with a fudge ganache, chopped Peanut Butter cups and chopped peanuts around the rim. This is a VERY rich-tasting cheesecake!

$40.00

Butterfinger® Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake) Chocolate cheesecake with bits of Butterfinger bars throughout, baked over an Oreo crust and covered with Reese's Peanut Butter frosting. If THAT wasn't enough, it's then topped with a Hershey's chocolate ganache and Butterfinger crumbs!

$35.00

Double Chocolate Italian Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): 16oz of BelGioiso Mascarpone cheese is blended with another 16 ounces of Philly cream cheese, then halved. One half of the mixture is blended with Hershey's semi-sweet chocolate, and the other half is blended with Hershey's white chocolate, giving you two levels of flavor. It's all baked into a crushed almond/vanilla wafer crust, and then the entire cake is completely covered with a semi-sweet chocolate glaze. Pricey? Yes. Rich-tasting and amazing? Absolutely!

$40.00

Chocolate Dream Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): 32oz of cream cheese is infused with Hershey's semi-sweet chocolate, and baked over a crushed Oreo crust. It's then topped with Cool Whip, Oreo dust, chocolate chips and crushed Oreo cookies. Yikes

$30.00

"Pigs in a Hot Tub" Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): This was a cake recipe that went viral over the Internet, but we put our own spin on it and turned it into a CHEESEcake! A 32oz Giordano's NY Cheesecake has a wall of Kit Kats built around it to make the "tub", then it's topped with melted Hershey's Chocolate for the "mud." It's completed with fondant pig figures and diving pig butts! Just a fun cheesecake, and it weighs a TON. Must be all the pigs! NOTE: We can also use white chocolate tinted blue for the "water"...just let us know!

$65.00

Triple Layer Strawberry Shortcake Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): This one's so in-depth that it takes two days to make it! All of the components are made fresh: 2 layers of shortcake, 1 layer of strawberry puree-infused cream cheese filling in the middle, layers of fresh-cut strawberries in between, and topped with our own cream frosting. It's then garnished with even more strawberries! This cheesecake more than 5 inches tall, and loaded with layers of strawberry goodness!

$45.00

Banana Pudding Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): 32oz of cream cheese is infused with real bananas and Jell-O banana cream pudding mix, and baked over a crushed Nilla Wafer crust. It's then topped with a layer of sliced bananas, Cool Whip, Nilla Wafers and Nilla Wafer crumbs

$35.00

Red Velvet Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): This is a triple layer cheesecake. Two layers of moist Red Velvet cake with a middle layer of cheesecake and cream cheese frosting throughout. Topped with more frosting and chocolate dust, and a cherry in the middle!

$40.00

Salted Caramel Cheesecake

PREMIUM (9" cheesecake): Salted caramel is very popular these days! And what better way to enjoy it than over two pounds of NY Cheesecake! We take our standard NY cheesecake and top it with homemade sea salt caramel and chopped pecans

$30.00

The Cherry Bomb

Sweet cherries and glaze are dolloped over a Pecan Sandy crust, topped with 32 ounces of our cheesecake batter, and topped with more cherries and a brown sugar crumble. It's literally an explosion of cherries!

$35.00

Please reload

bottom of page